Welcome to supreme pizza NY
Supreme Pizza NY, located at 44 Willoughby St, Brooklyn, is a celebrated spot for those craving authentic New York-style pizza. Known for its fast service and affordable prices, the establishment has transformed the classic dollar slice into a beloved selection, with toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and signature flavors. Patrons appreciate its quick turnover, ensuring fresh pies are always available, especially during lunchtime rushes. The friendly yet no-nonsense staff adds to the experience, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. In a city known for its pizza, Supreme Pizza NY truly stands out with its value and quality.
-
44 Willoughby St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States Hotline: +1 347-463-9595
Welcome to Supreme Pizza NY, the Brooklyn institution that has mastered the art of the quick, delicious slice. Nestled at 44 Willoughby St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, this gem has become a go-to for locals and visitors alike, serving up some of the best New York-style pizza in the area. With a phone number at +1 347-463-9595, ordering up your favorite slice has never been easier.
Supreme Pizza NY is not just about affordability, though that is a significant draw with its 99 cents for a regular cheese slice and an impressive range of toppings like pepperoni and sausage for as low as $2.50. Customers rave about the quality of the pizza; it’s consistent, fresh, and always hits the spot, especially when you need a quick meal during a busy day. Charlotte Richard notes the value in comparison to other spots in the city, emphasizing that while prices might have increased slightly, the quality remains unparalleled.
The atmosphere is bustling, especially during rush hour, but the efficient staff ensures that the experience is seamless. S, a regular, highlights the welcoming yet no-nonsense environment, where the employees are both quick and friendly, ready to prepare your slice with skill and speed. It’s evident that this is a place that thrives on its loyal customer base.
But it’s not just about the pizza—it's about the experience. Customers like Joe Frazier have witnessed the robust demeanor of the staff, which adds a layer of charm to the eatery. The lively interactions between patrons and employees showcase Supreme Pizza NY as a beloved community hub, where everyone knows they can count on a great meal at a fantastic price.
For those working nearby or just passing through, the convenience of late-night hours coupled with the swift turnover of fresh pies makes this spot ideal for any pizza lover. As Space Dandy points out, it’s the perfect place when you want something quick and satisfying that doesn’t empty your wallet.
Overall, Supreme Pizza NY is a slice of New York that encapsulates the essence of pizza culture in Brooklyn. With cheerful staff, a variety of flavors, and a focus on great value, this restaurant does more than just serve food; it creates an experience. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or sitting down for a meal, the combination of speed, taste, and price makes this a must-visit destination for anyone in the area.
This is a small space to order & take out. Probably because of tariffs and other fees, the pizza is now 1.25 or 1.50. I ordered a slice with pepperoni & sausage for 2.50 each and I bought 6 of them for 15. In my Marine Park neighborhood, I would have paid 5 or 6 for a slice with 2 toppings.
Watched the worker stand up to an angry customer. He wasn't scared at all. The degen left with his tail between his legs. It was awesome!! Love this place
Iconic (former) dollar slice spot on the corner - my favorite over the other spot down the block. They are fast and produce a solid, fresh slice with a good selection of flavors (white, marg, pepporoni, so on). It's always the same guys in there and boy are they holding it down - they are quick, efficient and simple take no sh*t. It can get a but busy and chaotic in there during rush hour as it is a beloved spot by people that work and attend school in the area but there's never a long wait. Note that they went up from 1 to 1.50 a slice last year (though they were one of the only spots I know to hold out that long even).
Quick, cheap, and consistent quality 1 pizza slice or 2 pepperoni slice. Don't expect top-tier slices, but it's great when you need a quick bite and something in your belly without hurting your wallet. It's convenient they are open late and pies turn over is fast. So, new pies are always coming out. 12/2023
Fast, cheap, delicious, and a very convenient spot to grab a couple of slices for lunch during my visit to Brooklyn for work. Got the cheese, pepperoni and pepperoni & sausage slices and liked them all. Little space in there so walked around till I found a spot to devour. Carries a sign of halal meat and the person at counter confirmed.
5/5 starts exactly what you expect. Cheap. Fast. Convenient. Wish chicago had 99cent pizza. Well done ! Btw you guys shouldn’t let costumers talk Back so rude i witnessed someone yelling at the cashier LOL
Their pizza is top notch for a regular plain slice! The cheese is very good and the dough is soft enough that you dont even have to toss out the bread ends of the the pizza. There are other dollar pizza spots but this by far tops that at the great value.
Very cheap New York style pizza. Regular cheese slice is only 99 cents. Topped skice are 2.5 doller.